Turkey Sliders : The Best Baked Mini Sandwiches for Any Occasion

Looking for the ultimate game day snack, holiday appetizer, or easy weeknight dinner? These turkey sliders are a go-to crowd-pleaser, combining juicy turkey, melted cheese, and a rich buttery glaze all baked to golden perfection. Whether you’re using leftover Thanksgiving turkey or deli slices, these mini sandwiches are simple to prep, irresistibly tasty, and adaptable to suit any gathering. In this article, you’ll discover the best way to make turkey sliders from scratch, explore fun variations, get serving tips, and learn how to keep them warm and crisp every time. Don’t miss our Slow Cooker Mississippi Chicken for another easy party favorite.

JUMP TO

Table of Contents

Why These Turkey Sliders Are a Must-Try

What Makes These Turkey Sliders Unique

These aren’t just your average mini sandwiches. The magic starts with layers of sliced turkey and melted provolone, stacked between soft slider buns. But what takes them over the top is the buttery topping—flavored with Dijon mustard, a hint of brown sugar, and everything bagel seasoning. As the sliders bake, the glaze soaks into the bread, creating a crispy, golden top and soft, flavorful interior that’s both sweet and savory.

Flavor Highlights: From Buttery Glaze to Melted Cheese

Each bite hits all the right notes: the saltiness of the turkey, the creaminess of the cheese, and that perfectly crisp, buttery finish. The everything bagel seasoning infuses bold flavors like garlic, onion, sesame, and poppy seeds—making these sliders taste far more gourmet than their simple ingredients suggest.

Best Times to Serve: Game Days, Holidays, or Quick Dinners

These turkey sliders are incredibly versatile. They shine as:

• Game day appetizers (set them out on a platter with dipping sauces)
• Holiday snacks (especially when you’ve got leftover turkey to use)
• After-school treats or quick dinners when you want something filling without fuss

Hosting a holiday gathering? Check out our Holiday Wreath Pizza for another festive bite-sized idea.

Choosing the Best Ingredients for Turkey Sliders

Types of Turkey: Deli vs. Leftover Roasted

You can’t go wrong with either option:

• Deli-style turkey is thinly sliced and layers neatly in sliders.
• Leftover roasted turkey adds a rustic, home-cooked texture that’s especially good after Thanksgiving.

Either way, opt for moist cuts like breast meat or shredded thigh pieces for the juiciest bite.

Cheese Options That Melt Perfectly

While provolone is the traditional pick for its mild flavor and excellent melting quality, you can get creative. Other great choices include:

Cheese Type	Flavor Profile	Melting Quality
Provolone	Mild, creamy	Excellent
Cheddar	Sharp, bold	Good
Mozzarella	Stretchy, neutral	Excellent
Muenster	Mild, buttery	Very good
Brie	Rich, slightly sweet	Soft melt

Looking for something festive? Try Cranberry Orange Preserves alongside Brie for a sweet twist.

Ideal Rolls: Hawaiian, Brioche, or Classic Slider Buns

The foundation of every great slider is the bread. Choose soft buns that absorb the buttery topping well without falling apart:

• Hawaiian rolls: Slight sweetness complements savory turkey
• Brioche buns: Rich and buttery
• Classic slider rolls: Simple and sturdy

Make sure the rolls fit snugly on your baking tray—no gaps means no mess.

Flavor Boosters: Brown Sugar, Dijon Mustard, and Bagel Seasoning

That glaze isn’t just butter. It’s a power combo:

• Dijon mustard adds tang and sharpness
• Brown sugar brings sweetness that balances the saltiness
• Everything bagel seasoning (garlic, onion, sesame, poppy) creates a crave-worthy crust

Don’t miss our Brown Butter Maple Blondies for a sweet treat to pair with your sliders!

How to Make Turkey Sliders Step-by-Step

Prepping the Rolls for Layering

Start by brushing your baking sheet with butter to prevent sticking. Slice your slider rolls horizontally and lay the bottom halves cut-side up on the sheet. This step sets the base for even layering.

Assembling the Filling: Turkey and Cheese Layers

First, layer your turkey evenly across the buns. Add provolone slices on top, then a second layer of turkey. This double-layer approach ensures the sliders are meaty and satisfying in every bite.

Place the top halves of the rolls on, gently pressing them down.

Creating the Buttery Topping Sauce

Melt your butter and stir in Dijon mustard, brown sugar, and everything bagel seasoning. Use a pastry brush to coat the tops of the rolls generously. The butter mixture will seep into the rolls as they bake, adding deep flavor and crunch.

Baking for the Perfect Crunch and Melt

Bake uncovered in a preheated oven at 350°F for 13–15 minutes. You’ll know they’re done when:

• The tops are golden brown
• Cheese is fully melted
• Bottoms are crisp but not burnt

Remove from oven, let cool slightly, then cut and serve.

Want to pair this with a holiday side? Discover great ideas like our Roasted Root Vegetables to complete the spread.

Variations to Try with This Turkey Sliders Recipe

Slider Add-ins: Bacon, Jalapeños, and Caramelized Onions

Want to level up your turkey sliders? Small tweaks can totally transform the flavor:

• Crispy bacon adds a smoky crunch that pairs beautifully with turkey and cheese.
• Sliced jalapeños bring heat and depth—perfect for spicy food lovers.
• Caramelized onions add sweetness and richness that makes each bite pop.

You can mix and match these to fit your crowd’s taste or the occasion. Looking for inspiration? Try our Stuffed Winter Squash Recipes for other cozy meal ideas.

Sauce & Spread Swaps: Cranberry Mayo or Spicy Mustard

Don’t stop at butter. Spreads can totally shift the vibe of your sliders:

• Cranberry mayo = Thanksgiving in a bite
• Spicy honey mustard = Sweet heat that cuts through the richness
• Herbed aioli = Creamy, garlicky goodness

Lightly spread your chosen sauce on the bottom buns before layering in the turkey.

Cheese Swaps: Cheddar, Mozzarella, Brie, and Beyond

Not into provolone? No problem. These cheeses all melt beautifully and change the flavor profile:

• Cheddar for sharpness
• Mozzarella for gooeyness
• Brie for a rich, buttery mouthfeel
• Smoked Gouda for earthy depth

Choose one based on your theme—classic, festive, or indulgent.

Serving Suggestions for Turkey Sliders

Best Dipping Sauces to Pair With

A dipping sauce can turn a good slider into a crave-worthy bite. Popular pairings include:

Sauce Type	Flavor Profile	Pairs Best With
Ranch Dressing	Cool, creamy	Bacon or spicy sliders
Honey Mustard	Sweet, tangy	Classic turkey cheese
BBQ Sauce	Smoky, bold	Cheddar sliders
Cranberry Sauce	Tart, sweet	Thanksgiving-style

You can even serve a trio of sauces for dipping variety.

What to Serve on the Side: Chips, Coleslaw, or Pickles

Sliders shine as the star of the plate, but sides add balance. Popular choices:

• Potato chips or sweet potato fries – simple and satisfying
• Coleslaw – offers cool contrast and crunch
• Dill pickles – acidity balances out richness
• Caesar salad – lightens things up with greens

Don’t miss our Shredded Brussels Sprouts Salad if you want something fresh and flavorful to serve alongside.

Serving for Parties, Potlucks, or Family Nights

These sliders are party-approved. Here’s how to serve them without hassle:

• At potlucks: Slice and wrap them in foil to keep warm on the go.
• At home: Leave them in the baking dish so guests can serve themselves.
• For picky eaters: Create a “slider bar” with optional toppings and sauces.

These flexible ideas make turkey sliders a hit in any setting.

Tips for Perfect Sliders Every Time

How to Keep Sliders from Getting Soggy

One of the most common complaints? Soggy bottoms. Here’s how to avoid it:

• Don’t overdo the butter glaze.
• Use thicker-sliced turkey instead of watery deli meats.
• Avoid assembling too early—moisture from the fillings seeps in over time.

A trick that works: Toast the bottom halves of the buns before assembly for a moisture barrier.

Reheating Without Drying Out

Leftover sliders reheat surprisingly well—if you do it right.

• Use a 300°F oven for about 10 minutes.
• Cover loosely with foil to retain moisture.
• Avoid the microwave—it makes the bread rubbery and the cheese unevenly melted.

For more reheating tips and cozy recipes, check out our Slow Cooker Beef Ramen.

Keeping Sliders Warm at Parties or Events

You can keep sliders hot without drying them out:

• Wrap the tray in foil and place it in a warm oven (170–200°F).
• Or keep them in a slow cooker on “warm” setting.
• Portable warmers or insulated food carriers also do the trick for potlucks.

That way, your sliders stay hot and gooey—never cold and chewy.

FAQs About Turkey Sliders

Conclusion: Why These Sliders Will Be Your New Favorite Recipe

With juicy turkey, gooey cheese, and that irresistible buttery topping, these baked turkey sliders are everything you want in a comfort food. They’re fast, flexible, and crowd-tested. Whether you’re planning a party, cleaning out the fridge after Thanksgiving, or just want something easy yet impressive for dinner—this is your answer. Add your own twist with bacon, spicy jalapeños, or different cheeses, and you’ll never run out of reasons to make them again. Looking for more cozy comfort recipes? Don’t miss our Cheesy Meatball Bombs—they’re just as irresistible.

Print