The Ultimate Thanksgiving Piecaken Recipe: A Showstopping Holiday Dessert

If you’re looking to create a dessert that wows everyone at the Thanksgiving table, then a Thanksgiving Piecaken is your ultimate showstopper. Combining classic holiday pies and moist cake into a single, jaw-dropping masterpiece, this dessert is every sweet lover’s dream come true. Whether you’re hosting Thanksgiving dinner or bringing a dish to share, this hybrid treat blends tradition with creativity in the most delicious way. Featuring rich layers of pecan pie, pumpkin pie, spice cake, and a luscious apple pie topping, all held together with creamy cinnamon frosting—it’s a dessert that demands attention.

Don’t miss our Soft Pumpkin Cookies with Cream Cheese Frosting for another fall-inspired favorite!

JUMP TO

Table of Contents

What Is a Thanksgiving Piecaken?

A Dessert Hybrid Like No Other

A Thanksgiving Piecaken is the ultimate dessert mash-up—pie meets cake in one stunning, multi-layered creation. Imagine slicing into a tall cake to reveal three decadent layers: a gooey pecan pie base, a creamy pumpkin pie center, and a spiced, fluffy cake on top. It’s then crowned with cinnamon cream cheese frosting and topped with apple pie filling, adding texture, flavor, and a beautiful finish.

This trend was first popularized by high-end bakeries and gourmet food sites like Goldbelly, but home bakers have embraced it for its dramatic look and comforting taste. Even if you’re not a pastry chef, with a little planning, you can absolutely pull this off in your own kitchen.

Why It’s the Star of Any Holiday Table

No matter how many desserts are at the table, the Thanksgiving Piecaken commands all the attention. It blends the most loved holiday flavors into one slice, eliminating the tough decision of choosing between pies or cake. Plus, it makes for a beautiful, Instagram-worthy centerpiece that leaves everyone asking for seconds.

Hosting Thanksgiving can be a challenge, but this easy Creaminess Baked Mashed Potatoes recipe pairs perfectly with a stunning dessert like Piecaken—bringing harmony to your menu from start to finish.

Ingredients You’ll Need for a Perfect Piecaken

To create the perfect Thanksgiving Piecaken, you’ll need components from several recipes. While this may seem like a lot, each element is simple and manageable—especially if prepared over two days.

Pecan Pie Layer Essentials

For the base layer, classic pecan pie brings a buttery, nutty crunch that anchors the dessert. Here’s what you’ll need:

• 9-inch unbaked pie crust
• 2 large eggs
• 1 cup light brown sugar
• ½ cup melted salted butter
• 1 tbsp flour
• 1 tsp vanilla extract
• 1½ cups chopped pecans

It’s important to cool this pie completely before assembly, or your layers may slide.

Pumpkin Pie Ingredients Breakdown

The middle layer is a pumpkin pie, which adds creaminess and warm spice. Combine the following:

• 9-inch unbaked pie crust
• 15 oz pumpkin puree
• ½ cup brown sugar
• ½ cup heavy cream
• 2 eggs
• 2 tsp pumpkin pie spice

Bake it on the lower oven rack to avoid soggy crust. Don’t miss our No Added Sugar Pumpkin Banana Bread for a healthy, flavorful option if you’re planning a second dessert.

Spice Cake Shortcuts (Boxed or Scratch)

The top cake layer adds height and structure. Using a boxed mix is totally fine:

• 1 spice cake mix
• 1 cup water
• ⅓ cup vegetable oil
• 3 eggs

Bake it in a 9-inch round cake pan lined with parchment. You’ll have extra—perfect for snacking while you build!

Homemade Apple Pie Filling Tips

For the crowning touch, homemade apple pie filling adds a pop of sweetness and texture:

• 1 lb apples, peeled and sliced
• 1 tbsp brown sugar
• 1 tbsp white sugar
• ½ tbsp flour
• ½ tbsp lemon juice
• 1 tsp cinnamon

Cook the apples until softened and lightly caramelized. This step can be done in advance and chilled.

Cinnamon Cream Cheese Frosting Must-Haves

Frosting ties everything together. This isn’t just decoration—it adds richness and balance:

• 8 oz cream cheese (room temp)
• 4 oz salted butter
• 4 cups powdered sugar
• 1–2 tbsp whole milk
• 2 tsp vanilla extract
• 1 tsp cinnamon

Mix until smooth and creamy. If needed, thin it slightly with milk to make it spreadable between layers.

For another dreamy fall dessert, check out our Salted Caramel Apple Bars—a perfect option for small gatherings or casual servings.

How to Make a Thanksgiving Piecaken from Scratch

Creating a Thanksgiving Piecaken might sound like a baking marathon, but with a little planning, it’s totally doable—even enjoyable. The key is to break down the components and make them ahead of time. Most of these layers can be prepped a day in advance, letting you focus on assembly and presentation when it matters most.

Baking the Pie Layers (Pumpkin and Pecan)

Start by making your pumpkin and pecan pies. These need to be fully cooled before stacking. Here’s how:

Pumpkin Pie:

1. Preheat your oven to 350°F.
2. Blend pumpkin puree, brown sugar, heavy cream, eggs, and pumpkin spice.
3. Pour into an unbaked 9-inch crust (placed on the bottom oven rack).
4. Bake for 45–50 minutes, until the center is set and doesn’t jiggle.
5. Cool completely, ideally overnight in the fridge.

Pecan Pie:

1. In a blender, mix eggs, brown sugar, melted butter, flour, and vanilla until smooth.
2. Add chopped pecans to the unbaked pie shell, then pour in the mixture.
3. Bake at 350°F for 35–40 minutes, until the filling is firm and slightly puffed.
4. Chill to set.

These pies are foundational. The better they’re set, the easier your assembly will be.

Looking for inspiration? Try our Pumpkin Brownies Recipe—another fantastic Thanksgiving hybrid!

Preparing the Moist Spice Cake Base

For the cake layer, you can use a boxed spice cake mix or make it from scratch. Here’s the shortcut version that saves time without sacrificing flavor:

1. Mix together 1 box spice cake mix, 1 cup water, ⅓ cup vegetable oil, and 3 eggs.
2. Pour into a parchment-lined 9-inch round pan.
3. Bake according to the box—typically 25–30 minutes at 350°F.
4. Let the cake cool completely.

Pro tip: Only one layer is needed, so freeze or snack on the extra!

Pair your piecaken prep with this cozy Cinnamon Apple Bread—an ideal breakfast while baking.

Simmering Apple Filling to Perfection

While your pies and cake are baking, cook the apple topping:

1. In a skillet, sauté sliced apples with brown and white sugar on low heat.
2. Add flour once juices release to thicken the sauce.
3. Stir in lemon juice and cinnamon for that classic apple pie flavor.
4. Let it cool before topping the cake.

This adds a fresh, juicy burst of flavor to balance the dense interior.

Whipping Up the Creamy Cinnamon Frosting

For the frosting, skip store-bought. This homemade cinnamon cream cheese frosting is worth the effort.

1. Beat softened butter and cream cheese until fluffy.
2. Slowly add powdered sugar, alternating with milk.
3. Mix in vanilla and cinnamon.
4. Adjust consistency for spreading and piping.

If you’re short on time, warm the frosting slightly for easier layering. For another rich dessert topping idea, don’t miss our Blueberry Cream Cheese Bars.

Assembling the Thanksgiving Piecaken Like a Pro

Now comes the fun part: bringing everything together into a glorious dessert tower. Assembly is easy if all layers are cooled and ready to go.

Tools You’ll Need (Cake Ring, Parchment, etc.)

To get clean edges and a professional finish, use an 8-inch cake ring and parchment or cake collar. You’ll also need a sturdy platter, offset spatula, and a serrated knife.

Cut the pies and cake with the cake ring for perfect alignment. Trim excess crust and edges as needed.

Stacking Order & Layering Tips

1. Set the cake ring on a flat plate or stand.
2. Place the pecan pie at the bottom. Spread a thin layer of frosting on top.
3. Add the pumpkin pie, then another layer of frosting.
4. Top with the spice cake layer.

At this stage, refrigerate the stacked layers for 1 hour. This helps the cake firm up and prevents sliding.

Frosting Techniques for a Smooth Finish

After chilling, remove the cake ring gently.

• Apply a crumb coat—a thin layer of frosting that traps crumbs.
• Chill again for 20 minutes.
• Finish with a thick, even coat of frosting around the cake.
• Use a piping bag to add rosettes or decorative swirls.

This technique makes your piecaken visually stunning and structurally sound.

Final Touches with Apple Pie Topping

Spoon the cooled apple filling into the center of the frosted cake. Pipe around the edge to create a border and help hold the apples in place. Optional: dust lightly with cinnamon or add chopped pecans for crunch.

Don’t miss our Cheesecake Fruit Salad Recipe—a lighter counterpart to this indulgent piecaken!

Expert Tips for Stunning Piecaken Results

Crafting the perfect Thanksgiving Piecaken isn’t just about the ingredients—it’s also about the little techniques that make the difference between good and unforgettable.

Make-Ahead & Freezing Instructions

Making the layers in advance is a game-changer. Chill each component overnight for easy handling the next day. After full assembly:

• Refrigerate for up to 4 days
• Freeze (unwrapped for 2–3 hours to harden frosting, then wrap in plastic and foil)
• Thaw overnight in the fridge before serving

Insert wooden skewers before freezing to keep layers from shifting. Remove before decorating.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

• Warm layers = frosting meltdown. Cool everything completely.
• Uneven cuts = sloppy assembly. Use a cake ring or trim with a serrated knife.
• Overfilling = oozing sides. Go light on frosting between layers.

Take your time and work in a chilled environment for best results.

Delicious Piecaken Variations You Can Try

While the classic combo is iconic, don’t be afraid to switch things up based on preferences or what’s already in your kitchen.

Swapping Cake Flavors (Chocolate, Vanilla, etc.)

Try a chocolate cake base with cherry and pecan pies, or go vanilla with apple and pumpkin. Spice blends well with nearly everything, but chocolate offers a rich contrast.

Looking for inspiration? Try our Black Magic Cake for a deep, decadent layer.

Alternate Pie Combinations (Cherry, Apple Crumble)

No rules say it has to be pecan and pumpkin. Cherry pie pairs well with vanilla or chocolate cake. Apple crumble pie adds texture and crunch.

Balance is key: mix one creamy pie (pumpkin) with one chewy or nutty one (pecan, apple, etc.).

Mini Piecakens for Individual Servings

Hosting a smaller dinner? Make personal-sized Piecakens using ramekins or jumbo muffin tins. Layer with pie crust pieces, fillings, and mini cake circles. These are great for portion control and presentation.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Conclusion – Make Your Thanksgiving Dessert Unforgettable

If you want a dessert that becomes an annual tradition, this Thanksgiving Piecaken is it. Rich, festive, and packed with the best seasonal flavors, it brings the “wow” factor to your holiday spread. From its creamy pumpkin and crunchy pecan layers to the soft spice cake and apple topping, every bite celebrates the season.

Check out our festive Christmas Fudge Recipe to keep your holiday dessert table vibrant and varied!

Print