Sugar Cookie Cheesecake – A Dreamy Holiday Dessert Worth Every Bite

Looking for the ultimate show-stopping dessert this holiday season? This Sugar Cookie Cheesecake blends the rich, velvety texture of classic cheesecake with the nostalgic sweetness of sugar cookies. Imagine a buttery shortbread crust, swirls of sprinkle-studded cookie dough, and a luscious vanilla-almond filling—all topped with a light, tangy sour cream frosting. It’s everything you love about festive baking rolled into one irresistible slice.

Whether you’re baking for a Christmas party, a cozy family gathering, or just because you’re craving something decadent, this dessert hits all the right notes. And the best part? You can make it ahead, decorate it in a flash, and savor every creamy, cookie-packed bite. Looking for inspiration? Try our Layered Pumpkin Cheesecake Recipe for a fall-flavored twist.

Let’s break down what makes this cheesecake a standout and how you can master it in your own kitchen.

JUMP TO

Table of Contents

What Makes Sugar Cookie Cheesecake So Special?

The Unique Twist of Sugar Cookie Dough in Cheesecake

This isn’t your average cheesecake. The secret sauce? Tiny sugar cookie dough bites folded into the batter, creating sweet pockets of buttery, sprinkle-laced joy in every slice. Unlike standard crust-only recipes, this dessert blends cookie elements throughout, giving it playful texture and sugary nostalgia.

How It Compares to Traditional Cheesecake Recipes

While classic cheesecakes lean on graham cracker crusts and smooth fillings, sugar cookie cheesecake amps up the flavor game. The almond and vanilla extracts add depth. The cookie dough provides chewiness. And the sour cream topping brings just the right tang to balance the richness. It’s layered, complex, and way more festive than your basic cheesecake.

The Perfect Holiday Treat – Festive, Rich, and Nostalgic

The holidays are about tradition—and sugar cookies are a staple in every home baker’s rotation. This cheesecake takes those warm memories and elevates them. Add red-and-green sprinkles or glittery sugar on top for a picture-perfect centerpiece. Check out our Christmas Tree Deviled Eggs Recipe for another fun holiday table addition.

Key Components of the Ultimate Sugar Cookie Cheesecake

Buttery Shortbread Crust – A Rich Foundation

Forget crumbly graham crackers. The shortbread base in this cheesecake is a dream. Made with flour, powdered sugar, salt, cold butter, and a splash of milk, it bakes up crisp yet tender. It supports the filling without overpowering it, letting the sugar cookie flavors shine through.

Discover great ideas like our Brown Sugar Pumpkin Loaf if you love buttery bakes that melt in your mouth.

Creamy Vanilla-Almond Cheesecake Filling

At the heart of it all is a lush, creamy batter. Full-fat cream cheese gives it body, while sugar, eggs, and sour cream bring that iconic tang. Vanilla extract delivers classic warmth, and a whisper of almond extract enhances the sugar cookie flavor. Don’t skip the room temperature rule—smoothness starts there.

Homemade Sugar Cookie Dough Bites

This eggless dough is simple yet brilliant. Butter, sugar, milk, flour, and a pinch of salt form the base, with colorful jimmies folded in for that sugar cookie vibe. Rolled into mini bites, they get stirred right into the cheesecake batter. When baked, they soften slightly, leaving behind chewy, sweet surprises.

Don’t miss our Pumpkin Cheesecake Dip Recipe if you want more creative cheesecake ideas with a twist.

Sour Cream Frosting with a Festive Touch

Finally, the sour cream frosting. This isn’t a stiff buttercream—it’s airy, slightly tart, and smooth enough to glide over your chilled cheesecake. Made with butter, sour cream, powdered sugar, and vanilla, it adds a light finish and hides any baking cracks with a snowy, whipped look.

Top it with holiday sprinkles, edible glitter, or crushed cookies for maximum impact. It’s the perfect balance to the dense, dreamy cake underneath.

Step-by-Step Instructions for Baking Sugar Cookie Cheesecake

Preparing the Shortbread Crust

The crust is the backbone of your cheesecake—it must be buttery, firm, and flavorful. Start by combining flour, powdered sugar, and salt. Add cold, cubed butter and mash it into the dry ingredients using your hands or a pastry cutter. Once the dough becomes crumbly, add a splash of milk to bind it.

Press the dough firmly into the base of a 9″ springform pan lined with parchment paper. Bake at 325°F for 18–20 minutes until lightly golden. This pre-bake ensures a crisp bottom that won’t go soggy once the cheesecake filling goes in.

Check out our Apple Cinnamon Oatmeal Cookies if you love buttery holiday flavors with a touch of spice.

Making the Eggless Sugar Cookie Dough

No need to worry about raw egg here—this edible dough is made with simple pantry ingredients. Cream together softened butter and sugar until smooth. Add milk and vanilla extract, then stir in flour and salt. For that festive sugar cookie effect, fold in colorful sprinkles last.

Roll the dough into small bite-sized balls and set them aside. These will be mixed into your batter, so don’t worry about perfection—they’ll soften and meld beautifully during baking.

Mixing the Cheesecake Filling

Start with room temperature cream cheese—it’s non-negotiable. Beat it slowly with sugar and a bit of flour until velvety. Then blend in sour cream, vanilla extract, and almond extract for flavor depth. Add the eggs one at a time, mixing gently to avoid air bubbles.

Once your batter is smooth, gently fold in the prepared sugar cookie dough balls with a rubber spatula. You want even distribution without overworking the batter.

Assembling and Baking with a Water Bath

Butter the sides of your pan and pour the batter over the cooled crust. Smooth the top. Then prep your easy water bath: place a large roast pan filled with boiling water on the bottom oven rack. Set your cheesecake on the middle rack above it.

Bake at 325°F for 1 hour and 15 minutes. Use the jiggle test to check doneness—if the center wobbles like Jell-O (not like soup), it’s ready.

Learn more about proper water bath baking in our Chunkin’ Chocolate Pumpkin Cheesecake post.

Cooling, Chilling, and Frosting

Once baked, turn off the oven, crack the door, and let the cheesecake cool inside for 45 minutes. This slow cool-down prevents sudden temperature changes that cause cracking.

After that, bring it to room temperature, then chill overnight. The next day, whip up your sour cream frosting and spread it over the top. Finish with festive sprinkles.

Don’t miss our No-Bake Chocolate Orange Cheesecake if you prefer chilled desserts without the oven time.

Common Issues and Troubleshooting Tips

Why Your Cheesecake Might Crack—and How to Fix It

Cracks aren’t always preventable, especially with cookie dough inside. As the dough releases steam, small air pockets can break the surface. But don’t stress—frosting covers everything beautifully. If you’re aiming for crack-free, remember:

• Always use room temp ingredients
• Mix at low speed
• Bake low and slow
• Cool gradually

Avoiding a Soggy Crust

A fully pre-baked crust is key to avoiding that dreaded soggy bottom. Also, be sure your pan is well-sealed, or use a crust that doesn’t rely on heavy moisture. Never skip lining the pan with parchment—it makes release easier and avoids sticking.

Preventing Over-Mixing and Lumps

Over-mixed batter introduces air bubbles and ruins texture. To keep it smooth and creamy:

• Stick to low-speed mixing
• Scrape the bowl often
• Add eggs one at a time
• Don’t whip—gently fold instead

Looking for more smooth, no-fail desserts? Try our Coffee Cheesecake Recipe for a café-inspired flavor profile.

Storage, Serving & Make-Ahead Tips

Best Way to Store Sugar Cookie Cheesecake

Once your cheesecake is fully chilled and frosted, it should be stored in an airtight container or tightly covered in plastic wrap. It’ll stay fresh in the refrigerator for up to 7 days, maintaining its creamy texture and cookie bite structure.

To serve, remove it from the fridge about 20 minutes before slicing—this softens the texture just slightly for the best bite.

How Long It Keeps Fresh

If you’re planning ahead, this dessert is a dream. After baking and chilling overnight, it can be stored whole or pre-sliced for easy plating later. It’s ideal for holidays when you need a fuss-free dessert that still wows.

Serving Ideas and Decorations for Holidays

Top with holiday-themed sprinkles, mini sugar cookies, or crushed candy canes. You can even tint the frosting lightly with food coloring to match your theme—pastels for spring, deep red and green for Christmas.

Want more holiday ideas? Check out our Christmas Salad with Honey Mustard Dressing for the perfect festive side dish.

FAQ About Sugar Cookie Cheesecake

Conclusion – Why You’ll Love Baking Sugar Cookie Cheesecake

This Sugar Cookie Cheesecake is more than just a dessert—it’s a joyful holiday experience. With layers of creamy vanilla cheesecake, festive sugar cookie dough bites, and a buttery shortbread crust, every slice is packed with flavor and fun. Top it off with sour cream frosting and sprinkles, and you’ve got yourself a crowd-pleasing masterpiece.

Whether it’s your first cheesecake or your fiftieth, this recipe makes holiday baking easy, exciting, and oh-so-satisfying. So go ahead—bake it, chill it, decorate it, and savor it.

Don’t miss our Christmas Sugar Cookies Recipe if you want another classic to add to your baking lineup.

Print