The Best Southern Tomato Pie Recipe for a True Taste of the South

Southern Tomato Pie isn’t just a recipe — it’s a story baked into a buttery crust, a tribute to ripe summer tomatoes, and a comfort food cornerstone in the American South. Whether you’re pulling fresh tomatoes from your backyard garden or stocking up at the farmer’s market, this dish transforms simple ingredients into something richly satisfying. In this article, you’ll learn what sets Southern Tomato Pie apart, how to avoid the most common pitfalls (like a soggy crust), and why this version is hands-down the best one to make. Plus, we’ll guide you step-by-step through prep, layering, baking, and serving it up like a pro.

Looking for inspiration? Try our creamy southern green bean casserole for a full Southern feast.

JUMP TO

Table of Contents

What Is Southern Tomato Pie and Why It’s a Beloved Classic

A Southern Staple with Deep Roots

Southern Tomato Pie is a quintessential warm-weather comfort food, especially in states like Georgia, Alabama, and Kentucky. With roots tracing back to rural Southern kitchens where nothing went to waste, it’s long been a way to showcase summer tomatoes at their peak. Unlike Northern or Italian tomato pies, this version features a savory filling in a golden pastry crust and is often eaten as a main course or side dish.

Southern vs. Italian Tomato Pie — Key Differences

Although they share a name, Southern and Italian tomato pies couldn’t be more different. The Italian version often resembles focaccia, baked on a thick rectangular crust and topped with sauce. Meanwhile, Southern Tomato Pie is a rich, savory custard-style pie, layered with sliced tomatoes, onions, herbs, cheese, and a mayo-egg binder. It’s creamy, cheesy, and often served in slices like a quiche or casserole.

Why It’s the Perfect Summer Pie

When tomatoes are sweet and abundant, this dish becomes a summer go-to. It’s ideal for brunches, light dinners, potlucks, and even holiday tables. Best of all, you can eat it warm, room temp, or cold — making it incredibly versatile. The combination of textures and flavors — juicy tomatoes, caramelized onions, creamy cheese, and a flaky crust — hits every savory craving.

Check out our roasted tomato basil soup for another way to use up summer’s tomato bounty.

Essential Ingredients for the Ultimate Southern Tomato Pie

Picking the Best Tomatoes for Flavor and Texture

Tomatoes are the star of the show, so don’t skimp. Choose ripe, meaty varieties like heirlooms, beefsteaks, or romas. Avoid watery salad tomatoes. Your goal is full-flavored, firm-fleshed fruit that slices cleanly and holds up in baking. Pro tip: Salt and drain the tomato slices on paper towels for at least 30 minutes. This draws out excess moisture and ensures your crust stays crisp.

The Importance of a Flaky Crust (Homemade vs. Store-Bought)

A homemade butter crust adds incredible flavor, but if you’re short on time, a deep-dish store-bought crust works just fine. Just be sure to blind bake the crust before filling — this means partially baking it empty so it doesn’t turn mushy. Use pie weights or dry beans to keep the bottom from puffing.

Cheese and Mayo — The Southern-Style Binder

Southern Tomato Pie wouldn’t be complete without its signature cheese-and-mayo filling. This creamy base brings the whole pie together. A mix of sharp cheddar and Swiss creates the perfect flavor balance — bold and nutty. Duke’s mayo is a classic choice in the South, but any good-quality mayo will work. Add a beaten egg to the mix for structure so the pie slices cleanly.

Discover great ideas like our classic homemade cranberry sauce for an ideal holiday pairing.

Enhancing Flavor with Onions, Herbs, and Breadcrumbs

Vidalia or sweet onions are sautéed until golden for a savory-sweet depth. Fresh basil adds brightness, and seasoned breadcrumbs between layers help soak up moisture while enhancing flavor. Want more kick? Add chopped green onions or a pinch of garlic powder to the mayo mix.

Don’t miss our perfect homemade stuffing recipe to build out your seasonal menu.

Step-by-Step Instructions to Make Southern Tomato Pie

Prep the Tomatoes to Avoid a Soggy Crust

This is the most critical step in the entire recipe. Tomatoes release a lot of juice when baked, which can turn your beautiful crust into a soggy mess. Here’s how to prevent that:

1. Slice your tomatoes about ¼ inch thick.
2. Spread them on a paper towel-lined baking sheet.
3. Sprinkle with kosher salt to draw out moisture.
4. Let them sit for 30 minutes, then pat dry thoroughly.

You can also take it a step further by baking the slices in a 300°F oven for 10–15 minutes to evaporate even more moisture. This works especially well with extra-juicy heirloom varieties.

Sauté and Cool the Onions for Extra Sweetness

In a skillet, heat olive oil over medium heat and sauté thinly sliced Vidalia onions until soft and caramelized on the edges — about 6 minutes. Let them cool completely before mixing them with the cheese filling. Cooking the onions first softens their bite and releases natural sugars, adding incredible flavor.

Layering the Pie — What Goes First and Why It Matters

Once your crust is blind-baked and cooled, here’s how to layer for the best texture and balance:

1. Spread half of the mayo-cheese-onion mixture on the bottom.
2. Sprinkle breadcrumbs — these act as a barrier and help soak up juices.
3. Layer half the tomatoes in a shingle-style pattern.
4. Repeat: more mayo mixture, more breadcrumbs, and remaining tomatoes.
5. Finish with shredded cheddar on top.

This layering locks in flavor and structure so that every slice holds together beautifully.

Check out our cheesy root vegetable gratin if you love golden baked dishes with layered goodness.

Baking It Just Right for the Perfect Golden Finish

Bake your assembled pie at 350°F for about 45 minutes. Look for these signs of doneness:

• The top is bubbling and golden.
• The cheese is slightly crisped at the edges.
• The center is set and no longer jiggly.

Let the pie rest for at least 20 minutes before slicing. This helps it firm up and makes serving cleaner and easier.

Tips, Variations, and Expert Hacks

How to Keep Your Crust Crisp Every Time

• Blind bake the crust and cool it before filling.
• Use a ceramic or metal pie plate (glass holds more moisture).
• Add a breadcrumb layer between filling and tomatoes.
• Bake on a preheated sheet pan to crisp the bottom faster.

These four tricks make all the difference in preserving the crust’s integrity.

Flavor Boosters: Bacon, Dijon, or Fresh Garlic

Want to punch up the flavor?

• Add crumbled bacon between the tomato layers for a smoky twist.
• Mix 1 teaspoon Dijon mustard into the mayo mixture for tang.
• Stir in minced garlic or garlic powder for more depth.

You can also sprinkle crushed red pepper flakes for a spicy bite.

Learn more about layering bold flavors in our bourbon peach upside-down cake — a must-try dessert!

Cheese Swaps: From Swiss to Gouda and More

While Swiss and cheddar are the go-to combo, feel free to experiment. Here are some great alternatives:

Cheese Type	Flavor Profile	Best Paired With
Gruyère	Nutty, rich	Dijon, leeks
Mozzarella	Creamy, mild	Basil, garlic
Colby Jack	Buttery, melty	Spicy mayo, bacon
Feta (crumbled)	Tangy, salty	Olives, oregano
Gouda	Smoky, sweet	Smoked paprika

Mix and match based on what you have in your fridge.

Gluten-Free or Vegetarian Options

• Gluten-free? Use a gluten-free pie shell and almond flour or GF breadcrumbs.
• Vegetarian? You’re already there! Just skip the bacon if using.
• Dairy-free? Sub in vegan mayo and cheese blends — just expect a softer set.

Don’t miss our hearty and cozy cozy fall potato soup for an easy pairing idea.

Serving Suggestions for Southern Tomato Pie

Best Pairings for Brunch, Lunch, or Dinner

Southern Tomato Pie is wonderfully versatile — serve it as a brunch centerpiece, a summer lunch, or a savory side at dinner. Pair it with:

• A light arugula or mixed greens salad with vinaigrette
• Fresh corn on the cob or corn salad
• Cucumber and onion salad for contrast
• A slice of melon or seasonal fruit
• A glass of iced tea or rosé wine

Discover great ideas like our tomato cucumber and onion salad for the perfect pairing.

Should It Be Served Warm, Cold, or Room Temp?

The short answer: all of the above. You can enjoy it:

• Warm from the oven (ideal for dinner)
• Room temperature (great for brunch or picnics)
• Chilled (surprisingly delicious in summer heat)

Let it rest at least 20 minutes before slicing — this helps the filling set up perfectly.

How to Store and Reheat Without Ruining Texture

For best results, eat the pie the day it’s made. However, if you’ve got leftovers:

• Store tightly wrapped in the fridge for up to 3 days
• Reheat in a 325°F oven for 15–20 minutes to maintain crust crispness
• Avoid microwaving — it’ll soften the crust too much
• Do not freeze — the texture won’t hold up due to tomatoes and mayo

Frequently Asked Questions About Southern Tomato Pie

Final Thoughts: Why This Is the Best Southern Tomato Pie Recipe You’ll Ever Make

Southern Tomato Pie is the kind of dish that turns everyday ingredients into something magical. The layers of sweet tomatoes, golden onions, herbed mayo, and melting cheese all wrapped in a flaky crust — it’s everything a comforting Southern recipe should be. Whether it’s your first time making it or you’re a seasoned pro, this version delivers crisp texture, deep flavor, and nostalgic charm in every slice.

Looking for inspiration? Try our cucumber avocado salad for a refreshing side dish that complements tomato pie beautifully.

Print