Soft Sourdough Sandwich Bread: The Perfect Everyday Loaf

Soft sourdough sandwich bread is the perfect balance between the deep flavor of traditional sourdough and the pillowy softness we crave in everyday sandwich loaves. Whether you’re a seasoned home baker or trying your hand at sourdough for the first time, this recipe offers an easy, approachable method to create a loaf that’s light, soft, and flavorful—without the hard crust or dense crumb typically associated with sourdough. In this article, we’ll walk you through every step, from feeding your starter to baking and storing your loaf, so you can master the art of soft sourdough sandwich bread right in your kitchen.

Looking for inspiration? Try our moist lemon bread with glaze if you’re into tender, flavorful loaves.

JUMP TO

Table of Contents

Understanding What Makes Soft Sourdough Sandwich Bread Special

Why Sourdough Bread Isn’t Always Soft

Most people picture sourdough as a crusty artisan loaf with a chewy interior and big air pockets. While that style has its charm, it doesn’t always work for everyday uses like sandwiches or toast. Traditional sourdough often lacks the softness and structure that’s ideal for spreading peanut butter or building a stacked deli sandwich. That’s because classic sourdough focuses on wild fermentation and high hydration, which creates an open crumb and firm crust.

Soft sourdough sandwich bread takes a different route. Instead of a crusty, chewy bite, this variation aims for a tender crumb, smooth structure, and subtle sour tang that won’t overwhelm your toppings. The texture is more uniform and the crust is thinner—ideal for slicing and toasting.

Benefits of a Soft Crumb Loaf

When you bite into soft sourdough sandwich bread, you’ll immediately notice how gentle it is on the palate. This makes it a great option for kids, picky eaters, or anyone who finds crusty sourdough too rough. The uniform texture also helps keep sandwich fillings in place, making lunch prep easier and cleaner.

Another major plus? It’s freezer-friendly and holds up well in lunchboxes. Check out our easy meatballs and gravy recipe for a delicious sandwich filling idea to pair with your fresh loaf.

Key Ingredients for a Soft Finish

Achieving a soft crumb requires a few key tweaks to your usual sourdough routine:

• Milk or milk powder: Adds fat and lactose, both of which contribute to a softer crumb and better browning.
• Butter or oil: Fats tenderize the dough, locking in moisture.
• Eggs (optional): Enrich the dough further, giving it structure and a richer flavor.
• Bread flour: Has higher protein than all-purpose flour, which helps with gluten development and structure—important when baking in a loaf pan.
• Sugar or honey: Just a touch will boost browning and balance the natural sour flavor.

You don’t need fancy ingredients—just the right balance. And yes, this bread is still fermented naturally, so you’re not missing out on those sourdough health benefits.

Step-by-Step Guide to Making Soft Sourdough Sandwich Bread

Preparing the Sourdough Starter

The foundation of a good sourdough loaf is an active starter. Make sure yours is fed and bubbly before mixing your dough. Ideally, feed it 4–6 hours before baking with a 1:1:1 ratio (equal parts flour, water, and starter by weight).

Signs your starter is ready:

• Doubled in size
• Bubbly and airy
• Passes the float test (a small scoop floats in water)

Avoid using sourdough discard for this recipe—it needs a fully active starter to lift the enriched dough properly.

Mixing and Autolyse Process

Start by combining your flour and liquid (water or milk) and let the mixture rest for 30–45 minutes. This rest period—called the autolyse—allows enzymes in the flour to activate, which enhances dough extensibility and helps the gluten form naturally. After autolysing, mix in your starter, fat (butter or oil), and salt.

A sample base formula for one loaf:

Ingredient	Weight (grams)
Bread flour	400g
Whole milk	250g
Active starter	100g
Unsalted butter	40g
Salt	8g
Honey (optional)	15g

Mix until combined. You don’t need to knead aggressively. A few rounds of stretch-and-folds will do the trick.

Don’t miss our crusty Italian bread recipe if you’re in the mood for something more rustic.

Bulk Fermentation and Stretch & Folds

Bulk fermentation is where the magic happens. Let the dough rest for 4–5 hours at room temperature, performing stretch-and-folds every 30–45 minutes for the first 2 hours. This helps strengthen the dough without intensive kneading.

You’ll know bulk fermentation is complete when:

• The dough is puffy and airy
• It has risen by about 50%
• It jiggles slightly when shaken

Watch out: Overproofing leads to a gummy crumb and poor oven spring. Warm kitchens can speed this up, so adjust timing as needed.

Shaping and Final Proofing for Sandwich Loaves

Tips for Shaping into a Pullman or Standard Loaf Pan

Shaping is crucial when it comes to sourdough sandwich bread. You’re aiming for a tight, even structure that will rise neatly and slice beautifully. Whether you’re using a Pullman pan for a square loaf or a standard loaf pan for a dome shape, the method is mostly the same.

After the bulk ferment, gently deflate your dough and turn it onto a lightly floured surface. Pat it into a rectangle, then roll it up tightly like a jelly roll. Pinch the seams closed and place the dough seam-side down into a well-greased loaf pan.

Make sure the dough fills about two-thirds of the pan to allow room for proofing.

Check out our croissant bread loaf recipe if you’re craving another soft and buttery bake.

Cold Retard vs. Same-Day Baking Methods

Now you have two options:

• Same-day bake: Let the dough proof at room temperature for 1.5 to 2 hours until it rises slightly above the rim of the pan.
• Cold retard (overnight): Cover and refrigerate the loaf for 8–12 hours. This enhances flavor and makes the dough easier to score and bake.

Both methods work well. For an extra-smooth crumb and gentle sour tang, cold proofing is the way to go.

A good test: Press your finger gently into the dough. If the indentation springs back slowly and partially, it’s ready to bake.

Baking Techniques That Ensure a Soft Crust

Covered Pan vs. Open Bake

To maintain softness, consider baking in a covered pan or tenting foil over the loaf for the first half of the bake. This traps steam, which keeps the crust thin and soft.

Alternatively, you can bake in a steamy oven by placing a tray of hot water at the bottom of the oven.

Ideal bake settings:

• Preheat oven to 375°F (190°C)
• Bake for 35–45 minutes, depending on pan and oven
• Internal temp should reach 190–195°F (88–90°C)

Once baked, cool in the pan for 10 minutes, then transfer to a wire rack to cool fully.

Don’t miss our fluffy ciabatta bread recipe if you want to explore more tender bread options.

Storing, Slicing & Customizing Your Sourdough Loaf

How to Store for Softness and Freshness

To keep your soft sourdough sandwich bread tender for days, storage matters. Avoid refrigerating it as that can dry out the crumb. Instead:

• Wrap in plastic or beeswax wrap
• Store in a bread box or airtight container
• Freeze slices for up to 2 months (just toast to revive)

For even longer shelf life, wrap individual slices in parchment and freeze in zip-top bags. This keeps the bread tasting fresh with minimal fuss.

Slicing Tips for the Perfect Sandwich Slice

Once cooled, use a serrated bread knife to slice. For cleaner cuts:

• Wait until the loaf is fully cooled (2+ hours)
• Use a gentle sawing motion
• Slice from the side if you want thinner cuts

This bread holds together well even for thin slicing, making it perfect for delicate sandwiches or thick breakfast toast.

Discover great ideas like our pumpkin pie bread pudding with challah to use up extra slices in the most delicious way.

Add-ins and Variations You Can Try

This base recipe is super flexible! Here are some tasty twists:

• Honey Oat: Brush the top with milk and sprinkle rolled oats before baking.
• Whole Wheat: Replace 25–30% of the flour with whole wheat for a nuttier flavor.
• Milk Bread Style: Add tangzhong (a pre-cooked flour paste) for an ultra-soft Japanese-style loaf.
• Savory: Add shredded cheese, herbs, or even chopped olives for a sandwich-ready savory bread.

Customize to suit your cravings—just make sure not to overdo add-ins so the loaf retains its structure.

Frequently Asked Questions About Soft Sourdough Sandwich Bread

Conclusion: Start Baking the Softest Sourdough Loaf at Home

Soft sourdough sandwich bread is a game-changer for anyone who loves sourdough but wants a gentle, sliceable loaf perfect for daily use. With the right ingredients, techniques, and proofing practices, you’ll be pulling the softest, most delicious loaf out of your oven in no time.

Whether you’re layering deli meats or spreading homemade jam, this bread holds up beautifully. Ready to level up your sourdough game? Try this recipe, and you’ll never go back to store-bought sandwich bread again.

Looking for inspiration? Try our Texas Roadhouse rolls recipe next—you’ll love the fluffy texture!

Print