Old-Fashioned Sweet Potato Casserole

Q: How do I make it less sweet?

Cut both sugars in the base by half and use unsweetened mashed sweet potatoes . You can also skip the topping entirely or go with a savory breadcrumb crust instead.

Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe

Nothing says holiday comfort like a warm dish of Old-Fashioned Sweet Potato Casserole. Whether you’re prepping for Thanksgiving, Christmas, or just craving a cozy, sweet-savory side, this dish brings family traditions to the table in the most delicious way. We’re diving into the roots of this classic recipe, exploring every detail from choosing the right sweet potatoes to mastering that crunchy pecan topping (or marshmallow if you’re team fluff). You’ll also learn how to prep it ahead of time, make it freezer-friendly, and even adjust it to suit your dietary needs.

Looking for inspiration? Try our Fluffy Sweet Potato Pancakes Recipe to kickstart your day before diving into casserole prep.

JUMP TO

The Tradition Behind Sweet Potato Casserole

A Holiday Staple with Southern Roots

Sweet potato casserole has long been a beloved dish across Southern kitchens, deeply rooted in hospitality and seasonal harvests. It’s a standout on festive tables not just for its sweet flavor, but also for its ability to balance out rich, savory entrées like roasted turkey or glazed ham. Over time, it’s become more than a side—it’s a nostalgic centerpiece that sparks memories of family gatherings, passed-down recipes, and second helpings.

Why “Old-Fashioned” Still Reigns Supreme

The term old-fashioned here isn’t just for charm. It refers to time-tested methods that focus on wholesome ingredients—roasted sweet potatoes, real butter, eggs, vanilla, and a golden topping made from pecans and brown sugar. This isn’t a shortcut recipe. It’s one that respects flavor, texture, and the ritual of holiday cooking. While modern versions with shortcuts exist, there’s unmatched depth in this version that comes from slow baking and thoughtful layering.

Pecan vs. Marshmallow: A Delicious Debate

Here’s where preferences get personal. Some folks swear by the classic crunch of a pecan streusel topping—crispy, caramelized, and deeply flavorful. Others lean into the gooey nostalgia of toasted marshmallows, golden on top and melty underneath. The good news? This casserole accommodates both. In fact, if you’re feeling bold, you can even combine the two. The old-fashioned recipe typically leans pecan, but flexibility is part of the tradition.

Ingredients that Make the Difference

Choosing the Right Sweet Potatoes

Not all sweet potatoes are created equal. For that signature color and flavor, opt for varieties like Jewel, Garnet, or Beauregard, all of which boast deep orange flesh and a naturally sweet profile. Baking them whole intensifies their flavor, caramelizing the sugars and giving your base that creamy consistency you can’t achieve with boiling.

Must-Have Pantry Staples

The ingredient list is simple, but every element matters. You’ll need both granulated and brown sugar to achieve that layered sweetness. Unsalted butter ensures a rich, indulgent base without going overboard on salt. Eggs give the filling structure and fluffiness, while pure vanilla extract adds warmth. Don’t forget a pinch of salt—it’s what makes the sweet flavors pop.

Here’s a quick breakdown:

Ingredient	Purpose
Sweet potatoes (4 large)	Main base – creamy and flavorful
Granulated sugar	Sweetness with structure
Brown sugar	Caramel depth and richness
Butter (unsalted)	Smooth texture and flavor
Eggs	Binding and fluffiness
Vanilla + Salt	Balances and enhances flavors
Pecans, Flour, More Sugar	For that irresistible streusel topping

Check out our Baked Sweet Potato Recipe for tips on getting your base perfectly tender.

Toppings That Elevate Flavor

The classic topping features a crumbly mix of chopped pecans, light brown sugar, flour, and melted butter. Once baked, it forms a crackly, golden layer that contrasts beautifully with the soft, smooth base. Want a twist? Toasted mini marshmallows can easily take its place. They’re especially popular with kids—and kids-at-heart.

Don’t miss our Pecan Pie Dessert Recipe for a rich, Southern dessert pairing.

Step-by-Step Guide to the Perfect Casserole

Baking the Sweet Potatoes for Peak Flavor

Begin by selecting four large, orange-flesh sweet potatoes—Jewel or Garnet are top choices. Preheat your oven to 425°F and line a baking sheet with foil. Wash, dry, and prick each potato a few times with a fork. Bake them for 45 to 60 minutes until they’re fork-tender and caramelized at the edges. This process concentrates their sweetness and eliminates the wateriness you get from boiling.

After baking, reduce your oven temperature to 375°F—a key step before baking the full casserole.

Don’t miss our Roasted Sweet Potato Soup Recipe for another way to use baked sweet potatoes.

Mixing to the Right Texture

Once the potatoes are cool enough to handle, peel and transfer them into a mixing bowl. Using a stand mixer or hand mixer, beat the potatoes with ½ cup granulated sugar and ½ cup brown sugar until smooth.

Next, add ¾ cup softened butter and beat again until the mixture becomes light and airy. Add 4 room-temperature eggs, 2 teaspoons vanilla extract, and 1 teaspoon salt. Beat thoroughly until the color lightens and the texture is silky yet fluffy.

This base should be smooth and slightly thick—it’s what gives the casserole its signature texture. Pour it into a greased 9×13-inch dish and spread evenly.

The Ultimate Pecan Topping (or Marshmallow Swap)

While the base is baking for 30–35 minutes, mix together the topping:
– ¾ cup brown sugar
– ¾ cup chopped pecans
– ⅓ cup flour
– ½ teaspoon salt
– ¼ cup melted butter

Stir until crumbly. After the first bake, spread this mixture evenly over the casserole and return it to the oven for 10 more minutes. For a crisp, golden finish, broil for 1–2 minutes at the end—just don’t walk away!

If you prefer marshmallows, skip the pecan mix and add a 10-ounce bag of mini marshmallows instead. Bake until golden brown, about 10 minutes, or broil briefly for that classic toasty look.

Looking for inspiration? Try our Sweet Potato Biscuits Dessert Recipe for another comforting side.

Pro Tips for Baking & Finishing Touches

Use room-temperature eggs and butter for a smoother mix.
Avoid overbaking—the center should be set but still slightly jiggly after the first bake.
Add the topping only after the initial bake to prevent burning or sinking.

If you’re serving multiple courses, consider our Mushroom Herb Stuffing Recipe to balance the sweet with something savory.

Make-Ahead Tips and Storage

How to Prep Sweet Potato Casserole in Advance

You can absolutely prep this dish ahead of time—perfect for stress-free holidays.

1 to 2 Days Before: Bake and mash the sweet potatoes, mix in sugars, butter, eggs, and vanilla. Pour into the dish, cover tightly, and refrigerate. Prepare the dry topping ingredients separately (minus butter) and store in a container at room temperature.
Day Of: Let the casserole sit at room temp for 1 hour. Bake as directed. Mix in the melted butter with your topping and proceed with the second bake.

Freezing and Reheating Without Losing Texture

To freeze, prepare the filling and place it in a foil-wrapped dish—don’t bake yet. Freeze for up to 3 months.

To Use: Thaw in the refrigerator for 24–48 hours, then bring to room temp before baking. Add your topping before the second bake, and finish with a quick broil if desired.

Reheating leftovers? Cover loosely with foil and warm at 325°F. The topping may lose some crunch, but the flavor stays spot-on.

Check out our Creamy Slow Cooker Mashed Potatoes if you need another make-ahead side to round out your meal.

Keeping the Topping Crunchy

For best texture, only add the topping right before baking. If it sits too long with butter, it may get soggy. Also, avoid covering the dish while warm—it’ll steam and soften the crunchy layer. Let it cool uncovered for at least 10 minutes before serving.

Customization Ideas to Make It Yours

Healthier Variations Without Losing Flavor

If you’re watching your sugar intake, try cutting both the granulated and brown sugar in half. Use unsweetened applesauce or maple syrup as a natural sweetener alternative. You can also swap out butter for coconut oil to reduce saturated fat. Subbing in whole wheat flour for the topping can add fiber without compromising crunch.

Want something a little lighter? Try using egg whites instead of whole eggs or mix in Greek yogurt to create a creamier texture with less fat.

Vegan and Allergy-Friendly Options

Making this recipe vegan is easier than you’d think. Use flax eggs (1 tbsp ground flaxseed + 3 tbsp water per egg), and replace butter with a high-quality plant-based alternative. Swap regular sugar for organic cane sugar and maple syrup to ensure everything is vegan-friendly. For nut allergies, ditch the pecans and top your casserole with pumpkin seeds, crushed pretzels, or oat streusel for texture.

Small-Batch or Crowd-Size Adaptations

Cooking for two? Halve the ingredients and bake in an 8×8-inch dish. Feeding a crowd? Double the recipe and use two 9×13 pans. This casserole is flexible enough to fit any gathering size, making it the perfect holiday companion whether you’re hosting a Friendsgiving or a family reunion.

Don’t miss our Easy Creamy Cheesy Potato Bake Recipe if you’re planning a full comfort-food spread.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Can I use canned sweet potatoes instead of fresh ones?

Yes, but the flavor won’t be as rich. If you’re short on time, use two 29-ounce cans, drain them well, and reduce the sugar slightly to avoid an overly sweet casserole.

What’s the best way to reheat leftovers?

Reheat in a 325°F oven covered loosely with foil for about 20 minutes. Avoid microwaving if you want to preserve the crunchy topping.

Is sweet potato casserole a dessert or a side dish?

Traditionally, it’s a side dish—but with its sweetness and buttery topping, it certainly doubles as dessert for many households.

How do I make it less sweet?

Cut both sugars in the base by half and use unsweetened mashed sweet potatoes. You can also skip the topping entirely or go with a savory breadcrumb crust instead.

Can I freeze the unbaked casserole?

Absolutely. Assemble the filling in your dish, wrap tightly, and freeze for up to 3 months. Thaw in the fridge and bake as directed before adding the topping.

Conclusion: Bring Back the Comfort with This Classic Dish

Old-Fashioned Sweet Potato Casserole brings more than flavor—it brings tradition, warmth, and that unmistakable comfort only a holiday classic can offer. With a silky base and crisp topping, it’s a dish that delivers on nostalgia and indulgence in every bite. Whether you’re sticking with tradition or tweaking it for dietary needs, this casserole is endlessly adaptable.

Don’t miss our Classic Pumpkin Pie Dessert Recipe to complete your holiday dessert table.

Table of Contents